- Most viewed
- Last viewed
The UIC Faculty of Law has brought together experts to discuss the legal limits of artificial intelligence and its impact on citizens' rights in areas such as healthcare, consumer protection, public administration and intellectual property, as part of a research project funded by the Government of Catalonia
To what extent do existing laws protect us when a machine makes decisions on our behalf? To explore this question, Universitat Internacional de Catalunya (UIC) recently hosted the round table “The Regulation of Artificial Intelligence: Challenges for the Catalan and Spanish Legal Systems”. The event also served to present the findings of a Faculty of Law research project awarded a grant by the Centre for Legal Studies and Specialised Training (CEJFE) of the Government of Catalonia.
Organised by Marc Simon Altaba, lecturer in Commercial Law and principal investigator of the project, the event examined how technological change is reshaping sectors as creative as culture. In the field of intellectual property, he argued that the real “battlefield” is not so much who signs an AI-generated work, “but rather the raw material used to train the models”. He added that “for years, copyright-protected material has been fed into servers and the companies developing this technology are unable to explain why AI produces the results it does”.
The impact of digitalisation on the public sector was the focus of contributions by Montserrat Nebrera, dean of the Faculty of Law and lecturer in Constitutional Law, and Juan José Guardia, lecturer in Administrative Law at the University of Barcelona. Nebrera stressed that, although AI is neither inherently good nor bad, careful attention must be paid to the risks it poses to fundamental rights, including privacy and the right to effective judicial protection. “AI in public administration should have its own compliance framework, overseen by a human being,” argued the Dean, concluding that “legitimate public-sector AI must be understandable, open to review and accountable”.

Guardia warned of the dangers of the so-called “black box” and the unpredictability of AI algorithms, which are based on statistical probabilities. To address this uncertainty, he called for “the application of the principle of human oversight, whereby citizens have the right for their case to be reviewed by a person rather than a machine”.
In the field of consumer protection, Maridalia Rodríguez, lecturer in Civil Law, highlighted how AI-driven personalised digital environments can influence consumers’ decisions without their knowledge. “The decision is ultimately made by the consumer, but the environment has been designed so that the customer enters it without having given explicit consent and that is where the problem lies,” Rodríguez warned.
Finally, vice-dean and lecturer in International Law Maria Mut brought the discussion into the healthcare field through the use of so-called “digital twins”. Mut warned of the risks of placing blind trust in computer simulations designed to predict disease in real patients. “We cannot confuse a digital patient, which operates within a mathematical system, with a real patient, who may not behave in the same way,” she said, adding that “the law should not be limited to regulating the data used to train these models, but must also safeguard patients' rights”.
The event brought together around 20 attendees, including students, teaching and research staff, professional and administrative services staff, former students and others interested in the challenges that artificial intelligence poses for the law and the legal system.
